Advanced Search





Article Archives Search

Archives

  • April, 2013
  • March, 2013
  • February, 2013
  • January, 2013
  • December, 2012
  • November, 2012
  • select

AE Monthly

AE Reviews

 
Fascinating and Important Manuscripts from Michael Brown Rare Books

A drawing, likely of


By Michael Stillman

Michael Brown Rare Books has published one of the most thoroughly described catalogues we have seen: Manuscripts. Letters, Correspondence, Diaries and Archives. These are, naturally, one-of-a-kind items, and Brown has chosen to print extensive selections from those being offered. This catalogue employs 148 large pages of small type to cover 83 items. The result is a detailed look not only at the particular items, but of the time and places described in these hand-written documents. You will come away with a greater understanding of and appreciation for what life was like in early America, the source of most of these documents.

There are three items of particular historic significance being offered. We will describe these first, while recognizing that they are only within the means of institutional or very high-end collectors. However, the remainder of the documents are mostly within the range of more typical collectors, and while they may not be of quite such historical weight, they nonetheless offer a fascinating look at life in a very different America from the one we know today. We will also take a sampling of these other manuscripts, with a recommendation you contact Michael Brown to learn about the rest.

Item 40 is an extensive diary from New York's "Burned-over District" from Methodist circuit rider Rev. Benajah Williams. It contains around 4,600 pages from 1817-1862, the later years spent at Chagrin Falls, Ohio. Much of this comes from the period of the Second Great Awakening in upstate New York, when religious fervor in what was still something of a frontier led to new religious and social practices. It was a period of growth for the Shakers and Millerites, the latter of whom disappeared when their date for the Second Coming of Christ came and went. It was also a time of growth for the abolitionist, temperance and feminist movements. Perhaps of greatest note, Williams served in Mendon, then home of Brigham Young, and just west of Palmyra, the hometown of Latter Day Saints' (Mormon) founder Joseph Smith. His diary sheds important light on what is known as Joseph Smith's "First Vision." Smith reported that he received his first vision of God, which is generally considered to be the beginning of the Mormon religion, in an orchard after a revival meeting in 1820. However, skeptics have claimed there was no such meeting near Palmyra in 1820, the only ones having taken place in 1817 and not again until 1824. They have claimed this throws suspicion on the accuracy if not the honesty of Smith's claims. However, Williams' manuscript diary describes a two-day Methodist revival meeting at Richmond, 30 miles from Palmyra, and 19 miles from the Coates farm where then 14-year-old Smith was working. Allen Coates, who hired Smith, was a devout Methodist, and Coates' grandson later said that his grandfather had taken young Smith to a Methodist revival, and after that, Smith had gone off to an orchard and had a vision. This is consistent with Smith's version. Williams' diary appears to support one of the fundamental but controversial claims by Joseph Smith pertaining to the beginnings of the Mormon Church. Priced at $300,000.

Fascinating and Important Manuscripts from Michael Brown Rare Books

Rare first edition of report from Seneca Falls women's rights convention.


Item 82 is an exception to this catalogue as it is a printed document, but with a hand-written presentation from a critical participant. It is a copy of the original Report of the Woman's Rights Convention, Held at Seneca Falls, N.Y., July 19th and 20th, 1848. This was the first women's rights convention, in effect, the birthplace of the movement. Brown notes that this is an exceptionally hard to find document. There are seven copies in institutions, but he has found no copies sold at auction in at least 100 years, nor records of any private sales, and he notes that great collectors such as Streeter did not possess first editions such as this. This report contains Elizabeth Cady Stanton's The Declaration of Sentiments, and it is one of only two known copies with a presentation in Stanton's handwriting (this one is clear, while the other presentation is smudged and not as obviously Stanton's writing). The presentation states simply "Mr. John Gay." Gay was a prominent businessman in Seneca Falls. Stanton's Declaration of Sentiments begins, "The history of mankind is a history of repeated injuries and usurpations on the part of man toward woman, having in direct object the establishment of an absolute tyranny over her." The gauntlet was thrown down, and Stanton's dream of women gaining their "unalienable right" to vote was finally achieved in 1920. $500,000.

Item 35 is a lost manuscript account of widespread travels throughout what was the American West of 1808-1810 by one John Maley. Maley called his book, which was never published, An Account of Four Years Travels through the Illinois, Indiana, Louisiana, Missouri and Mississippi Territories with a True and Accurate Account of Every Principal River West of the Mississippi from the Missouri down to the Red River... This was still in the era of Louis and Clark and Zebulon Pike, so an account of such extensive travels is truly an amazing and important find. Maley tells of the natural history, and the white and Indian settlements throughout this wide area. Little is known about Maley, and his life and book might better be described as "unknown" rather than "lost" but for the presence of a second manuscript held by Yale University. That manuscript covering 1810-1812 picks up mid-sentence, implying this earlier account. The second manuscript reached Yale through a gift from Professor Benjamin Silliman, who likely purchased it from New York, later Philadelphia bookseller Isaac Riley. Maley sold his accounts to Riley, undoubtedly expecting they would be published. Silliman was interested in the "Texas Iron," a huge meteorite that had struck Texas and was once a revered item by local Indians. Maley described the Texas Iron in his second journal, perhaps explaining why Silliman purchased only the second one. The existence of this earlier journal, though implied by the second, has otherwise been unknown. There has been some questioning of the accuracy of Maley's claims in the second journal. The problem is that almost nothing is known of him to provide verification. He was born around 1776 in New York, and died in South Carolina in 1819. A judge he befriended in his later years described him as a "wanderer." The journals he wrote were evidently written after his travels, probably around 1815, so they would be based on memory. Certainly this new journal is a great source for scholarship about the early West, and maybe now that his account is complete, we will one day see their publication, even if a couple of centuries late. $575,000.

Fascinating and Important Manuscripts from Michael Brown Rare Books

Rev. Benajah Williams' extensive diaries.


Item 17 is two unpublished 1803 Fourth of July orations by Nathaniel Paine Denny, an ardent Federalist from Massachusetts. Delivered in Leicester, Massachusetts, Denny defends Adams and Washington, and attacks Jefferson. Many of his attacks on Jefferson are oblique, being aimed at southerners and Virginians instead (never mind Washington was a Virginian). The ever-diplomatic Denny orates, "School houses in Virginia are as rare as Brothels in New England & places of public worship as unfrequented, as horse races in Massachusetts." One might interpret this as meaning that Virginians were highly educated and pious, though it is unlikely this was Denny's intent. $1,250.

Item 54 is an odd combination, two 1850s business day books of Pennsylvania merchant Cyrus Betts whose back pages were later used for a diary by Rachel Smith, a young Quaker woman related to Betts. Smith has obviously been filled with a terrible sense of sin and guilt. She refers to herself as "wicked" and "sinful," describing herself as a "carnal minded girl and unfit for any hereafter." She returns from a Quaker meeting and writes, "Oh what a poor miserable sinner I am." After she discovers a lump in her breast, she becomes fearful and writes, "I am too sinful to receive rightly my maker when He knocks at the door of my heart. I am very much depressed for I fear my doom is to be an awful one." Weren't these times tough enough without people subjecting themselves to such awful psychological abuse? $1,250.

Item 64 is an autographed letter from Samuel Green Arnold, who served as governor of and senator from Rhode Island in the 19th century. In this 1847 letter, the then 25-year-old Arnold writes, "...I have brought up my cousin for years to make her my wife, for I am so fastidious & particular on that matter that I knew I never should find a lady to suit me in all respects unless I educated her for the purpose. This is an original idea to be sure but it is a fact I can recommend..." Original, for sure, but strange as well. However, Arnold must also have had a wandering eye, for he speaks of going to a dance to be attended by the daughter of a Mrs. Carr: "...I went to the ball expressly to see the daughter in a low neck dress." His purpose was to check out his friend's claim to her having extraordinarily large breasts. He was not disappointed, noting he had never seen "a more delightful vision," though adding she was "too full for beauty." This man must have made an ideal senator. $500.

Item 65 is a letter from F.B. Bigeler of Bangor, Maine, to a friend. He describes another friend's suicide after being told by his wife she did not love him, and then goes on to speak of the death of a prostitute, along with providing advice good to this day. He writes, "52 of us went through that poor girl and then she died. No wonder Tob. got the clip clap. Bill Smith did. Bill Hall and I didn't. We had on a cow-catcher..." $1,000.

Item 18 is a diary from prickly schoolteacher Alexander L. Gordon of Brookville, Pennsylvania. He notes that he is quite unpopular with the mothers of the community, but points out that he really doesn't care. At one point he explains, "I am informed today that Mrs. Andrews has taken her daughter Marg. away from school for the reason that I wiped [whipped] her." No wonder he wasn't popular. $1,750.

Michael Brown Rare Books may be reached at 215-387-9808 or mbamericana@mindspring.com. Their website is found at www.mbamericana.com.