AE Monthly

<b>Bonhams:</b> MANDELSHTAM, OSIP. 1891-1938. Autograph Manuscript, 2 pp, [Petersburg,] January 1913, entitled

Article Archives Search

AE Articles


The Government Faces Off Against a Collector for a Declaration of Independence - By Michael Stillman Turn of the Century Wiscasset, from the period when the Declaration was in the home of Town Clerk Sol Holbrook. By Michael Stillman Another case involving "lost" public documents is playing out in a Virginia court, the type of case we both hate to see and expect to see more of in the days ahead. It pits a public authority against an innocent collector, the latter standing to lose hundreds of thousands of dollars as a result of a purchase made in good faith. There must be a better way. The item is a copy of the Declaration of Independence, not the first printing, but a very early one, from 1776. It was printed in Salem, Massachusetts, and apparently went to the Town of Pownalborough in what was then northern Massachusetts. The town is today known as Wiscasset and what was then northern Massachusetts is now known as Maine. Somewhere along the way, as Massachusetts lost Pownalborough and Pownalborough lost its name, Wiscasset lost its copy of the Declaration of Independence. Today it is in the possession of Richard L. Adams of Virginia. Obviously, he believes he is the owner. He would not have paid $475,000 to borrow it for a few months. Exactly what happened to it between 1776 and 2008 is not certain, but here is what appears to have occurred over the last hundred years or so. It apparently was held by Sol Holbrook, a watchmaker by trade who was Wiscasset's Town Clerk from 1886-1929. It may sound odd, even questionable, that a town clerk would have had important public papers in his home, but those of us who have lived in small town New England will not be surprised at all. These towns would have had few, if any, public facilities, and no place to store the reams of public papers that accumulated over a century and a half. The one person who would be most likely to ever need any of these records would be the Town Clerk, so it is quite natural that they would end up in his house. And, while there might be some call for town minutes or the like from the past decade or so, the need to access records from the distant past would be negligible if not totally nonexistent. Most likely, the records, which included this Declaration of Independence, made their way to Holbrook's attic quite early in his town clerking career, and never saw the light of day again. After Holbrook died, no one came to reclaim the records for the town. It is likely after all of those years no one knew what he had, and no one cared. So the records ended up in the attic of Holbrook's daughter, Anna Plumstead. It's doubtful either she or her father ever had any idea there was something valuable in there. When she died in 1994, her belongings were put up for auction, and that was when it became clear there was something of value. At that 1995 estate auction, it sold for $77,000. Since then, it has gone through a couple of private sales, at one time being held by London bookseller Simon Finch, before making its way to Adams. Now, Adams wants to sell it, and the State of Maine, which somehow missed the auction in Maine in which it was sold, has hightailed it down to Virginia to seize the copy.
The Government Faces Off Against a Collector for a Declaration of Independence - By Michael Stillman none Maine apparently has tough laws when it comes to retaking public documents. The state has already regained one town's copy of the Declaration of Independence, though that one was still within the state's borders at the time. We would agree that there is some legitimacy to this claim. Though no one ever stole this Declaration of Independence, it is also very unlikely that the town ever officially "de-accessioned" its copy either. They did not sell, give or throw it away. It just sort of faded from their possession. Now it's easy and logical to say this precious document, never given away by the town, still belongs to it. However, that leaves the vexing question: What of Mr. Adams? He did no wrong, had no reason to be suspicious, and has $475,000 tied up in the document. Is he simply out of luck? Should he be? And what of the thousands if not millions of other old government documents, long ago discarded under now unknown circumstances? Should collectors who paid good money in good faith for them be forced to turn them over free? Does the government get to undo decisions made a century ago to discard excess paperwork it no longer had room to store because today those papers are valuable? The law may make this document public property. Still, I don't believe the story should end there. Wiscasset may not have given the document away, but their placing it in private hands, and then ignoring it for a century, not unexpectedly led to Mr. Adams making a large and good faith investment in it. Obviously, the town, through its officials, had no idea this was their property, but that is not Mr. Adams' fault. Their failure to display even the slightest attributes of ownership or concern for their old papers for so long encouraged Mr. Adams, and his predecessors, to make good faith purchases. Now, the state claims Mr. Adams should pay for their negligence in caring for their property. Wiscasset had a century to reclaim the document, right up to the auction in 1995, with no one being harmed. It did not. And now, when some innocent individual is about to be seriously hurt, Maine suddenly makes its righteous claim. My opinion is that if the state has a valid claim, their negligence has caused Mr. Adams serious harm, and they are obligated to repair those damages. In this case, that amount is $475,000. And if they don't want to pay him damages, they should pay him $475,000 for all those years of storage.

The Government Faces Off Against a Collector for a Declaration of Independence

- By Michael Stillman

Turn of the Century Wiscasset, from the period when the Declaration was in the home of Town Clerk Sol Holbrook.

By Michael Stillman

Another case involving "lost" public documents is playing out in a Virginia court, the type of case we both hate to see and expect to see more of in the days ahead. It pits a public authority against an innocent collector, the latter standing to lose hundreds of thousands of dollars as a result of a purchase made in good faith. There must be a better way.

The item is a copy of the Declaration of Independence, not the first printing, but a very early one, from 1776. It was printed in Salem, Massachusetts, and apparently went to the Town of Pownalborough in what was then northern Massachusetts. The town is today known as Wiscasset and what was then northern Massachusetts is now known as Maine. Somewhere along the way, as Massachusetts lost Pownalborough and Pownalborough lost its name, Wiscasset lost its copy of the Declaration of Independence.

Today it is in the possession of Richard L. Adams of Virginia. Obviously, he believes he is the owner. He would not have paid $475,000 to borrow it for a few months. Exactly what happened to it between 1776 and 2008 is not certain, but here is what appears to have occurred over the last hundred years or so. It apparently was held by Sol Holbrook, a watchmaker by trade who was Wiscasset's Town Clerk from 1886-1929. It may sound odd, even questionable, that a town clerk would have had important public papers in his home, but those of us who have lived in small town New England will not be surprised at all. These towns would have had few, if any, public facilities, and no place to store the reams of public papers that accumulated over a century and a half. The one person who would be most likely to ever need any of these records would be the Town Clerk, so it is quite natural that they would end up in his house. And, while there might be some call for town minutes or the like from the past decade or so, the need to access records from the distant past would be negligible if not totally nonexistent. Most likely, the records, which included this Declaration of Independence, made their way to Holbrook's attic quite early in his town clerking career, and never saw the light of day again.

After Holbrook died, no one came to reclaim the records for the town. It is likely after all of those years no one knew what he had, and no one cared. So the records ended up in the attic of Holbrook's daughter, Anna Plumstead. It's doubtful either she or her father ever had any idea there was something valuable in there. When she died in 1994, her belongings were put up for auction, and that was when it became clear there was something of value. At that 1995 estate auction, it sold for $77,000. Since then, it has gone through a couple of private sales, at one time being held by London bookseller Simon Finch, before making its way to Adams. Now, Adams wants to sell it, and the State of Maine, which somehow missed the auction in Maine in which it was sold, has hightailed it down to Virginia to seize the copy.

The Government Faces Off Against a Collector for a Declaration of Independence

- By Michael Stillman

none

Maine apparently has tough laws when it comes to retaking public documents. The state has already regained one town's copy of the Declaration of Independence, though that one was still within the state's borders at the time. We would agree that there is some legitimacy to this claim. Though no one ever stole this Declaration of Independence, it is also very unlikely that the town ever officially "de-accessioned" its copy either. They did not sell, give or throw it away. It just sort of faded from their possession.

Now it's easy and logical to say this precious document, never given away by the town, still belongs to it. However, that leaves the vexing question: What of Mr. Adams? He did no wrong, had no reason to be suspicious, and has $475,000 tied up in the document. Is he simply out of luck? Should he be? And what of the thousands if not millions of other old government documents, long ago discarded under now unknown circumstances? Should collectors who paid good money in good faith for them be forced to turn them over free? Does the government get to undo decisions made a century ago to discard excess paperwork it no longer had room to store because today those papers are valuable?

The law may make this document public property. Still, I don't believe the story should end there. Wiscasset may not have given the document away, but their placing it in private hands, and then ignoring it for a century, not unexpectedly led to Mr. Adams making a large and good faith investment in it. Obviously, the town, through its officials, had no idea this was their property, but that is not Mr. Adams' fault. Their failure to display even the slightest attributes of ownership or concern for their old papers for so long encouraged Mr. Adams, and his predecessors, to make good faith purchases. Now, the state claims Mr. Adams should pay for their negligence in caring for their property. Wiscasset had a century to reclaim the document, right up to the auction in 1995, with no one being harmed. It did not. And now, when some innocent individual is about to be seriously hurt, Maine suddenly makes its righteous claim. My opinion is that if the state has a valid claim, their negligence has caused Mr. Adams serious harm, and they are obligated to repair those damages. In this case, that amount is $475,000. And if they don't want to pay him damages, they should pay him $475,000 for all those years of storage.